Tuesday, January 10, 2006

Said Zahari and ex-detainees to speak at arts forum

Straits Times,Jan 7, 2006
Ex-detainees to speak at local forum

By Ken Kwek

FORMER journalist and opposition figure Said Zahari is among a group of former political detainees who will speak at an arts forum next month.

Organised by The Necessary Stage, the forum on Feb 26 is part of the Singapore Fringe Festival.

The other speakers include two other ex-detainees, lawyer Tan Jing Quee and
former trade unionist Michael Fernandez. Also on the panel is playwright Robert Yeo, who wrote Changi, a tragic drama about political detention in which the lead character was inspired by Mr Fernandez.

They will take part in a discussion entitled 'Detention - Writing -

Mr Fernandez, 71, who was detained from 1964 to 1973 on suspicion of being a communist, said the forum was not a platform to argue his case politically or to refute the charges previously made against him.

'It is simply an occasion for healing, for sharing one's experience with a younger generation of Singaporeans who weren't around during those tumultuous years.'

Mr Said, 77, a Singapore citizen with Permanent Resident status in Malaysia, said he was 'rather surprised' to be invited to a public forum to air his views in Singapore, given his criticism of issues such as the Internal Security Act, which gives the Government powers of detention without trial.

'Such an event would not have taken place in the country even five years ago,' said Mr Said, who is now an academic in Kuala Lumpur. 'Perhaps there is a slightly more open political climate now,' he added.

The former editor of the Malay newspaper Utusan Melayu was also president of opposition party Parti Rakyat Singapura. In 1963, he was arrested in Operation Cold Store, a government security operation which saw 111 left-wing politicians and trade unionists being nabbed for suspected subversive activities.

He was released in 1979 at age 51 and became editor of the economic journal Asia Research Bulletin. He moved to Kuala Lumpur in 1992 and took up a fellowship four years later at the Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. The first volume of his memoirs Dark Clouds At Dawn was published in 2001. The second installment will hit Malaysian bookstores next month.

He is also the subject of a new film by local filmmaker Martyn See, titled Zahari's 17 Years.

Mr See, 36, has not decided when or where he will premiere his 50-minute film, but said he hoped it would not suffer the same fate as his last film.

Singapore Rebel, about opposition leader Chee Soon Juan's clashes with the Government, was deemed an illegal 'party political film' and banned by the Board of Film Censors last March.

Of his new film, Mr See said: 'Most Singaporeans, especially those from the younger generation, don't know who Said is. But his story is relevant, and offers an important if different view of Singapore's history.'

Today Weekend, January 7, 2006

Rebel See's new venture

Film-maker again makes documentary dealing with politics

Jeanine Tan

FILM-MAKER Martyn See, whose controversial 26-minute documentary Singapore Rebel was banned here on the grounds that it was a political film, has made yet another film dealing with politics.
The subject of his new 49-minute documentary, Zahari's 17 Years, is left-wing journalist Said Zahari, who was arrested in 1963 for allegedly being a communist.
Mr Zahari, 78, was detained without trial for 17 years in Singapore. Prior to his arrest, he had been banished from Malaysia for being a part of a strike involving Malaysian newspaper Utusan Melayu.
A Singapore citizen, he now lives in Kuala Lumpur.
"It would be irresponsible for me as a film-maker not to document Zahari because he was a major figure in Singapore's struggle for independence.
"He is a living document of the leftist struggle for independence," Mr See, 37, told Today.
"Zahari's story is an alternative take on the history of Singapore that was presented in the Discovery Channel's The History of Singapore."
Despite the trouble Mr See found himself in because of Singapore Rebel - his video camera and tapes were seized by the police - he does not foresee any problems with Zahari's 17 Years.
He started work on the documentary after he was inspired by talk of Mr Zahari when he attended the Freedom Film Festival in Malaysia in July last year.
The documentary was completed last week.
"I don't think Zahari's 17 Years contravenes the Films Act. It's not a party political film simply because Zahari is no longer a politician. It's non-partisan."
In an interview with Time magazine in December last year, Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew said in reference to Singapore Rebel, which chronicles opposition politician Chee Soon Juan's political activities: "Well, if you had asked me, I would have said, to hell with it.
"But the censor, the enforcer, he will continue until he is told the law has changed. And it will change ... "
"The making of Zahari's 17 Years wasn't intentional, the subject matter just came up.
"I find myself drawn to people who struggle against the odds."


Anonymous said...

You remorseless fool, I hope they arrest you for this new "party-political" film....since you learn nothing from your previous incident. Breaking the law is WRONG in Singapore. Everyone must obey the law and no one is above the law.

Your insistence in making party political films that are against the law in Singapore cannot be tolerated.

Such films evoke emotions in Singaporeans and motivate them to seek change. As our minister has explained in parliament, having emotions is highly dangerous and destabilising.

It is important to keep the political message clear and unambiguous so that the people are not awakened from their hibernation matrix ...their blissful existence as Singaporeans should not be disturbed.

Yours is a dangerous message one that undermines the fabric of our society...and harms our way of life. It is fully justified for you to be arrested fined and jailed under the film act.

BTW, how did you make the film?! I thought your camera has been confiscated!!!

Anonymous said...

EH anonymous...ur father lee kuan yew ah?!?! relak ah..maintain balance...its only a documentary..besides,you can choose NOT to watch it...so what's ur problem. I can see you wearing ALL WHITE everyday mr or miss PAP. Freedom of expression is NOT ur middle name...chill...peace out...

Anonymous said...


When can we see your new film? Will it be available online?


Anonymous said...

The first commenter was being ironic - i hope. It'd be seriously troubling otherwise but with Singaporeans - you really just can't tell...

Yes, please post it online! I thoroughly enjoyed "Singapore Rebel". I am not a fan of Chee but i think alternative perspectives are terribly important.